My Own Private Guantanamo

Pranks, Power and Pop Culture


Roger Ebert’s Letter
to a Young Film Critic

April 6, 2013

In September of 1987, I was 14 years old and just starting my sophomore year in high school. I was also a movie critic, having produced, with the help of my parents, a self-published newsletter of movie reviews since the 8th grade. I sent a few issues of my newsletter to one of my heroes, Roger Ebert, never expecting to hear back. One day, I opened my P.O. Box and found a letter sent from the offices of the Chicago Sun-Times. It was a response from Ebert, apparently typed on his personal computer and proofed by hand. Tonight, I was relieved to find this letter stuffed in a box of mementos my mom gave me when I moved away from home.

In 1987, Ebert’s words of encouragement made a strong impression on me, a brainy fat kid who felt less comfortable in his skin than in the darkness of a movie theater. I didn’t grow up to be a movie critic (or a journalist or an actor). But in that year, I began to feel more confident in myself as a writer. I found my voice, and in time, felt less awkward in my body.

Revisiting this letter, I am struck by its personal touch. He took issue with my opinions on a couple of movies (let’s face it, he was right about Beverly Hills Cop 2), just as he would any colleague’s. Ebert was also self conscious enough to proofread his own letter, perhaps realizing that I would find his typos. He closed the letter with his signature, and a red rubber stamp of his iconic thumbs up. I took this as a final gesture of encouragement.

In the last few days, many of Ebert’s friends, colleagues and readers have been sharing stories that confirm what a decent, down-to-earth and altogether generous human being he was. This letter is my contribution to those testimonials. Now that it’s been digitized, scanned, blogged, and tweeted, I’ve tucked the letter back into my box of childhood memories. Thanks for writing, Roger.


  • Johnny LUchador

    That is rad as hell. Seriously magical of him that he took the time to write you back

  • Mike Fraser

    That is awesome. Ebert was one of the few movie critics that I respected.

  • AK

    Well, honour his memory and kindness by reviving that and have a review website (non-commercial).

  • AK

    I used to find old reviews of him about a film that I suspected might be not what popular culture talks about that.

  • Josh

    A very touching article indeed

  • Rob Eberhardt

    Such a treasure :)

  • Two Thumbs Up Forever For Journalist and Iconic Film Critic Roger Ebert | Jeremy Goes to Hollywood

    [...] Roger Ebert’s Letter to a Young Film Critic ( Share this:TwitterFacebookLike this:Like Loading… Leave a Comment by jbvone on April 7, 2013  •  Permalink Posted in Film and Television Tagged Ann Landers, Chicago Sun-Times, Ebert, Ebert and Roeper, Film criticism, Gene Siskel, Hollywood Walk of Fame, Movie, Richard Roeper, Roger Ebert, Siskel and Ebert [...]

  • Influente | Capricii #pseudo# literare

    [...] letter Roger Ebert send a teenage boy who aspired to be a film critic. Also see Ebert’s advice on [...]

  • Adam Douglas

    Nice! I remember your newsletter. I credit it and movie sessions with you and your parents as helping me to develop a critical stance on film and media.

  • - Laurence Vincent

    [...] letter Roger Ebert sent a teenage boy who aspired to be a film critic. Also see Ebert’s advice on [...]

blog comments powered by Disqus